The Skepbitch

Scathing Skepticism and Social Commentary

Expensive Urine

My doctor recently informed me that I’m low in Iron. No, I’m not a pasty, pallid, vampirish white, as I’m not deficient as such, but my blood tests suggest that I am low in this necessary mineral.

Apparently, this is common in women of my age group. But don’t run away yet! I won’t start talking about menstruation, or my gynaecologist, and I promise to be skepbitchy…

The gist is, for the first time ever, I’m on prescriptive vitamins.

This gave me reason to ponder, just how many people need supplementary vitamins, as opposed to how many people take supplementary vitamins?

Are we just a bunch of pill-popping vitamin junkies?

A Pill-Popping Vitamin Junkie in action!

These aren’t the days of arduous sea voyages spanning many months, where passengers consumed a meagre, unvaried diet, and developed scurvy, with bleeding gums and sunken eyes.

Chances are, if you live in the ‘Western world’, even if you have a really shitty diet, you consume enough vitamins and minerals to avert being low, let alone deficient. Chances are, if you’re deficient, it’s some sort of essential condition, rather than diet-related neglect.

Yet the vitamin industry is a multi-billion dollar one!

Consumers are being duped into purchasing unnecessary drugs (yes, these fulfil the definition of drug) by their naturopaths, homeopaths, iridologists, chiropractors, herbalists, aromatherapists, chakra-aligners, acupuncturists, reflexologists, psychics, medical intuitives, osteopaths, massage therapists and aura readers.

Or…consumers self-diagnose.

Typing symptoms into search engines, we think (hope) we can ‘cure’ hemorrhoids with horse chestnut, and reverse male-pattern baldness with saw palmetto (men: I see you looking this one up now!).

All of a sudden, you’re an expert, recommending echinacea to your friends with the flu, and apricot kernels to those with cancer. Then you’re quaffing homeopathic sugar pills purported to retain the ‘memory’ of supposed ‘healing’ properties.

Say, did you know that a goiter can be cured by the touch of a hanged man’s hand?
The Hanged Man…hiding his hands from all of the scavenging goiter victims!

…I love my Mom, but she’s a classic example of such a consumer. Her goal is noble, to help her friends, and herself, but her methods are questionable.

Mom, never a day spent in Chemistry class, has her own chemistry set. An amateur apothecary, Mom makes her own moonshine… sorry, I mean colloidal silver. Quite simply, Mom synthesizes heavy metals for her own consumption. At the very least, ingesting these particles of silver could turn her skin an ashen-gray color by way of a disorder called argyria.

A Chemistry Set, for amateurs…

Often, a meal of tablets accompanies Mom’s meal. Heart condition? No. Chronic pain? No. Mom is a pill-popping vitamin junkie.

And so are many people.

But surely vitamins are natural, and safe?

But they aren’t invariably ‘natural’…have you forgotten that tablets are processed and factory prepared? They aren’t invariably ’safe’…for example, toxic levels (which aren’t always ridiculously high quantities of a vitamin) of Vitamin A can cause hair loss. Even taking saw palmetto won’t help you then…

So, before you go popping pills, in the hope of a miracle cure, or a bigger penis, or a libido to use that bigger penis, apply some critical thinking.

Do some real research (not reading the biased ‘product information’ listings online), try Pub Med rather than the Vitamin Shoppe, see a good doctor, and have a fucking orange, or something.
A fucking orange…

We obviously give a shit about our health, but not enough.

At the very worst, your unnecessary ’supplements’ can be contraindicated against your prescribed medication, and you can friggin’ die, man.

At the very best, you’ll have expensive urine…

January 14, 2008 - Posted by skepbitch | Alternative Medicine, Critical Thinking, Health, Pseudoscience, Skepticism, Vitamins | , , , , , , , , , , , | 7 Comments

7 Comments »

  1. Well written column. Thanks.

    I once had a friend who took a big bag of vitamin supplements every day because he thought it could counteract the unhealthy nature of his mostly fast food diet. It is amazing how easily people can fool themselves.

    Comment by Marf | January 15, 2008 | Reply

  2. I’m sure you didn’t just call iron a vitamin. Maybe my browser needs its rendering engine tuned.

    Otherwise, yeah, I visited an American expat living in Austria once, and there were cupboardfuls of pills and potions in his bathroom. Sheesh.

    Comment by Varn | February 6, 2008 | Reply

  3. Alcoholics and other drug addicts can get pretty short of various vitamins, as can folk with serious health conditions as you note. Better to deal with the underlying problems of course, but big-ass doses of the B group uppers while going cold turkey can help there too.

    Vitamin pills every day mostly just stop you absorbing any from food sources, leaving you at normal blood levels, and feeling like crap for weeks if you stop taking them (and providing a false sense of wellbeing if you quickly revert to taking them again).

    Making all that expensive pee can also damage your kidneys if taken to extremes for years.

    Oranges and other fruit are a much cheaper option if you’re not allergic to the ripening agents. Just remember to brush your teeth after any regular snacks of acidic foods.

    Comment by tussock | February 7, 2008 | Reply

  4. I think ‘vitamin’, as a non-specific variant of ‘tablet’ (‘vitamin tablet’ works, *’mineral tablet’ doesn’t) is an acceptable term for a supplement that also includes vitamins B (1-6), B12, Vit. C and Vit. H.

    Just in case, I’ll edit it so I don’t receive any further pedantic comments. :p

    Comment by skepbitch | February 7, 2008 | Reply

  5. Hi tussock. Thanks for your interesting comments and sensible suggestions. I’d never before heard of ‘vitamin withdrawal’…makes sense though.

    I agree with the kidneys comment. I would say that excessive, unnecessary tablets could affect your liver too.

    Comment by skepbitch | February 7, 2008 | Reply

  6. [...] homeopathic pills and a long list of unidentifiable, unnecessary tablets that make for expensive urine. You’d think she has heart disease or cancer…when she sits down to a meal, out comes a [...]

    Pingback by The things we do for love (and skepticism) « The Skepbitch | September 29, 2008 | Reply

  7. Good articles over all and this is also worthy of reading too. Expensive urine is all about kelation http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/2353632/the_absorption_factor_for_vitamins.html?cat=8

    Comment by george | November 8, 2009 | Reply


Leave a comment