The Skepbitch

Scathing Skepticism and Social Commentary

Jesus Hitler - The Moral Atheist

Jesus HitlerThe day I realized that I was an atheist I went on a murdeous, adulterous, blasphemous, idol-making, mother and father dishonoring, Sabbath-forgetting, thieving, coveting, false-witness-bearing rampage.

Not really.

A hemorrhoidically common assumption is that Atheists (the non-religious, Skeptics, Agnostics, etc.) are not moral people.

If it weren’t for laws, and the moral guidance of the religious, life would be one big Led Zeppelin backstage party.

After the party, there would be eternal hellfire and damnation. That’s one bitch of a hangover…

In a warped syllogism: Religious people are good. Atheists are not religious. Therefore, Atheists are bad.

Religion = Good. No Religion = Bad. Sounds kinda…I dunno, reductionist?

There is no original sin, and no original goodness. 

Human culture is replete with the over-simplified good versus bad dichotomy: God versus Satan, Super Hero versus Villain, and even internal Dr Jekyll/Mr Hyde struggles. The latter, in its less extreme form, is probably closer to the truth. In the words of the (n)ever popular song Ebony & Ivory, “There is good and bad in everyone.” Jesus had a bad temper, and Hitler was a Christian.

Good and bad are social constructs, and so are morals. Perceptions of good and bad, and notions of what is immoral or immoral change over time, and across cultures. For example, ‘Christians are good people’ is not a universal belief…

Importantly, the Church/Synagogue/Mosque/Temple, etc. aren’t the sole moral educators (or necessarily useful ones). Morals are mostly taught by our parents, our family, our friends, our schools, our universities, and our society. Then the wacky time comes when you have to understand right from wrong yourself - and take responsibility for any mistakes.

If you think that religion is a moral harness, then that says a lot about you. Is it only religion, not your own understanding of what’s right and wrong, that prevents you from wrongdoing?

Godless=lawless/badness is a successful stereotype. A generalization. Discrimination.

God=good is a self-perception of the holder of the belief. An unfounded sense of moral superiority.

Rosary beads wrapped around a machine gunHere’s where I’ll flex my stereotype muscles. (In my experience) the religious kids that I went to school with were hypocritical little fuckers who slept around, took drugs, drank, stole, lied…and went to church on Sunday. Jesus died for your sins - so, sin away - make it worthwhile!

I don’t need indulgences, confessions, pardons, OCD rosary beads, prayer, forgiveness, healing, flagellation, hair shirts, or Jesus…

The ‘moral’ of this story is: treat people as the individuals they are. Don’t make unfair assumptions about people you don’t know. Why not follow your own Golden Rule: ‘do unto those as you would have them do unto you?’ Or try Karl Popper’s modern twist of treating others as they want to be treated?

I can’t tell you how many times people have mistaken me for a Christian - friendliness and a smile do not a religious person make. There are bad Christians and good Atheists overall, and everyone’s a bit of both.

Don’t forget the research statistics of beliefs represented by prison inmates.

Skepticism, Atheism, Rationalism and other ways of thinking don’t aim to take away your culture, your values, your ideals, your ethics, and your morals. They aim to explain, and give truthful meaning to our existence.

So, come over to the ‘dark side’ sometime, where you might just find that enlightenment…

March 3, 2008 - Posted by skepbitch | Atheism, Skepticism, religion | , , , , , , | 9 Comments

9 Comments »

  1. Some people fear we shall descend into a black hole should we not think there is a god to judge us all and tell us what to think. That we need a divine purpose to be moral.

    Thankfully we do not need that assumption, and this was my response to the above charge in my blog:

    http://homoeconomicusnet.wordpress.com/2007/12/28/the-way-we-are/

    Comment by homoeconomicusnet | March 3, 2008

  2. I speak with some experience on this. Its indoctrination and then projection. Christians are indoctrinated to believe that they are filthy savages. They can’t believe that God saves them unless they need saving. Truly believing that they are only a prayer away from blood lust and an orgy, they project this believe onto others. *sigh* I confess I sort of hoped that when I stopped professing Christianity Satan would attack my struggling faith with hordes of nubile coeds, but sadly, no

    Comment by truthwalker | March 4, 2008

  3. Good post, and I agree wholeheartedly that there are both good and bad apples in both groups (Christians, atheists, other groups too for that matter). You might like a similar blog post of mine titled “On Atheism and Civic Inclusiveness” at
    http://jeffreyellis.org/blog/?p=82.

    Comment by jeffreyellis | March 5, 2008

  4. Well-said, well-said. One of the best essays on this subject I’ve read in a long time. One of the best ever, really.

    Unfortunately I can’t write a lengthy critique; I have to meet some fellow non-believers in a few minutes. We’re going to rape and pillage the families over in the next cul-de-sac.

    Comment by skidoo | March 6, 2008

  5. I tried having a dark side. Hell, I tried being a Goth. Too naturally damned cheerful though. *sigh*
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Top1wmRzS9c

    Comment by podblack | March 8, 2008

  6. [...] the brick of rationalism hit me over the head (and other tangled metaphors). As an epilogue to my Moral Atheist blog entry, and another tool in the armory of the Atheist, the Skeptic, and the [...]

    Pingback by Happy Easter! « The Skepbitch | March 23, 2008

  7. Hey, badmouth Jesus all you want, but Ebony & Ivory was a #1 hit, and spent 4 weeks on the top of Billboard’s charts.

    Comment by Jeremy | March 27, 2008

  8. This was very well written, and thought out, and I adored it. It can’t possibly get any worse, this christian problem, so why don’t we solve it their way?

    Burn them at the stake?

    Comment by Lyanvis Suzusuke | April 1, 2008

  9. Dear Skepbitch I happened to come across your article on the net while doing research on the Templar Knights (AH the internet never know where you will end up). I want to tip my virtual hat to you. I am much older than thee I just figured this out last year for myself. Keep writing. Best wishes Eva

    Comment by eva magnusson | April 27, 2008

Leave a comment