The Skepbitch

Scathing Skepticism and Social Commentary

The things we do for love (and skepticism)

On a recent visit, my brother Kalvin asked me, “What did we eat when we were growing up?”

I stared at him in disbelief. “You must have repressed memory syndrome,” I teased. “How could you forget the tofu? The wheatgerm? The lecithin?”

Five years older than me, he admitted coolly, “I probably drove out for a hamburger afterwards.”

Long before it was cool in California to add soymilk to your latte… before hummus was fashionable… when most families would come home to ”meat and three veg”, I’d be coming home to a wholewheat vegetarian lasagne with spinach, ricotta and brown rice.  

I was the gastronomic outcast in school; the wretched, miserable kid with the Nutmeat and tahini wholewheat sandwich. I was the kid with the carob ‘chocolate’ easter eggs…

It all began when my mother developed a series of nasty non-specific symptoms. She had heart palpitations. She lost weight. Her hair fell out. She was up cleaning the bathroom at 2am.  It was like she was on speed. She was suffering from a thyroid condition. She was sick, scared, vulnerable, and the symptoms never completely disappeared…

Thus began her life-long alternative medicine quest…

She has visited naturopaths, homeopaths, trichologists, herbal medicine ’specialists’, reflexologists, diet gurus, reiki masters, acupunturists, bowen therapists, chiropractors, osteopaths, iridologists, and other peculiar practitioners that don’t even have names…

Yeah. That’s my Mom.

She takes garlic and horseradish tablets, spirulina, echinacea, Vitamin C, Vitamin B complex, multi-vitamins, “Pluton” homeopathic pills and a long list of unidentifiable, unnecessary tablets that make for expensive urine. You’d think she has heart disease or cancer…when she sits down to a meal, out comes a plastic tray of pills. As my step-father says, “She eats more pills than food.” She’s dabbled in most fad diets, but worst of all, she used to make her own collodial silver…

She’s been visiting with me for the past few weeks, so let me tell you about my most recent tiff with her…and you’ve heard these arguments before…

Years ago she saw a chiropractor who ‘massaged her chest’ (yep…I’m a Dr., let me massage your goddamn bollocks). He caused extensive bruising and she suffered breathing difficulties for weeks. Fortunately, an x-ray revealed no internal damage.

I confronted her about this touchy topic…

“So, you’re still seeing that nutjob chiropractor, Mom?” In her ashamed admission of betrayal, like a cheating spouse or a naughty boy found with porn under the bed, she nodded, and looked away, ”I didn’t want to tell you that I’m still seeing him.”

“I’d just assumed you still were,” I replied honestly.

“Well, I just see him for my general well-being, for colds, headaches. It helps with everything really.”

“But there’s no evidence that this works. In fact, there’s a substantial amount of evidence to the contrary!”

Then she became defensive with urgent appeals. I was attacking her intelligence, and her sincere hope that it works. “They don’t have the funding that big pharmaceutical companies have! There’s a lot we don’t understand, Karen. There’s got to be something to it. So many people use it! It helps relieve my shoulder pain. I have to try everything.”

“But you’re also seeing a doctor, a physiotherapist, and a masseuse. You use creams. With all that you wouldn’t know what’s actually working. In the end it doesn’t work because the pain’s still there!”

“He does it to his two toddlers too. He wouldn’t do it to them if he thought he could injure them. He treated his daughter when she was one day old.” Now this really pissed me off…

“Mom, you could’ve had your ribs cracked or your lungs punctured by that fucking ignorant prick!”

…silence…

Now I’d done it! I’d upset my tiny, gentle, sensitive, ever-smiling yet now teary-eyed mom. What a skepbitch I am.

I calmed down, put my arm around her, and said earnestly, “I need to make you aware of the risks. I don’t want you to be hurt. Because I love you.”

And now she’s gone home. And here I sit with reminders of her… a box of Zen Therapeutics Ki Immune Defence & Vitality Formula, a jar of Ascorbate C with lemon bioflavonoids, rosehips, and hesperidin, and a vial of homeopathic pills.

Because she loves me…

September 29, 2008 - Posted by skepbitch | Skepticism | , , , , , , , , | 17 Comments

17 Comments »

  1. You did your mom good service; be proud of that. Maybe dial down the profanity next time.

    Comment by Transplanted Lawyer | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  2. You were honest and showed why; be proud of that. Maybe dial up the profanity next time, or else I’ll think you’re getting soft on us… ;)

    Comment by podblack | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  3. Being honest with family can be tough. However, in my humble (but correct) opinion, you did the right thing, and for the right reasons.

    Comment by John T | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  4. [...] The things we do for love (and skepticism) September 30, 2008 Posted by Skepdude in Skepbitch. Tags: alternative medicine, chiropractor, Colloidal Silver, diets, homeopathy, iridology, naturopathy, reflexology, Vitamins trackback CLICK HERE TO GO TO THE ORIGINAL ENTRY AT “SKEPBITCH” [...]

    Pingback by The things we do for love (and skepticism) « Skepfeeds-The Best Skeptic blogs of the day | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  5. Oh, Karen, that’s rough. I wonder how many skeptics became such watching a family member hurt themselves. My dad went to AA, NA, and OA. I watched him be anointed with oil, prayed for, and prayed at. He regularly tries colloidal silver, tomato juice, aloe vera juice, yerba mate, and various mushrooms. Some quack even talked him into coffee enemas for awhile. None of it works, of course. He’s still getting sicker. Turns out that his radical conversion doesn’t save him from the consequences of 15 years IV drug abuse. I wish he could accept it, and spend the last years of his life doing things he loves instead of taking pointless pills, because I love him. He prays for me everyday, because he loves me.

    Comment by truthwalker | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  6. The Vitamin C, at least, will do no harm, and may do some good. The rest…

    Read: http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/

    That is, if you don’t already.

    Comment by Fragano Ledgister | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  7. Thanks for your comments, all.

    Fragano – there’s some evidence to suggest that Vit. C taken, when not deficient, can overstimulate the immune system in some people, exacerbating some conditions.

    Israel – I’m very sorry to hear that, mate. :( I really don’t think my experience is a unique one, at all.

    Transplanted Lawyer – I’m softness, smiles, skepticism and frequent coarse language. If that’s your advice, you missed my point, and haven’t read http://www.bad-language.com

    Comment by skepbitch | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  8. I take vitamins on doctor’s orders. And most of my Vitamin C comes the natural way, from fruit.

    Comment by Fragano Ledgister | September 30, 2008 | Reply

  9. Fragano – a recent update on Vit. C:

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7643533.stm

    Comment by skepbitch | October 1, 2008 | Reply

  10. [...] A personal story of alt. med. obsession – If the true believers get to use emotional appeals through personal anecdotes, why can’t we? Especially since we have the evidence as well. [...]

    Pingback by News From Around The Blogosphere 10.1.08 « Skepacabra | October 1, 2008 | Reply

  11. I feel your pain. :( I wish so much that I could talk my parents out of their wackier beliefs.

    Comment by The Perky Skeptic | October 2, 2008 | Reply

  12. I have a similar relationship with my Mom. It is very difficult to discuss things of this nature and I have stopped being negative and pick my spots. I try to ask questions and make suggestions but not trash all of her beliefs. For example, the other day I asked her if she tells her pharmacist and doctor about any vitamins and herbs without specifically throwing science at her.

    I try to get her to reference legit sources for info and plant seeds of information and try to foster a sense of critical thinking. It’ll probably never happen completely but it’s the way I decided to approach it.

    Comment by WTF Chuck? | October 2, 2008 | Reply

  13. So Vitamin C, by protecting mitochondria in all cells, helps out cancer cells. Hmm.

    Comment by Fragano Ledgister | October 3, 2008 | Reply

  14. That was an incredible story, made me sad as we all seem to know someone we care about and want tell them how there are other ways of going about things. The fact that you are able to speak your mind with such an open honesty (as you call yourself “the skepbitch”) and compassion…. well all I can say is your made of awesome. Being honest and compassionate can come with a stigma (as in “you’re just putting on a show to make yourself look better” or an arrogant stance on something) when in actuality all you are being is a true, sincere, sweet, genuine person. Cheers ~t

    Comment by Mr. Blue Bubbles | October 4, 2008 | Reply

  15. [...] sick? I haven’t, but if I were to I wouldn’t be taking any advice from a Doctor such as Karen Stollznow over at the skepbitch! She doesn’t even condone the use of popular “alternate” medicines such as [...]

    Pingback by Skeptics of Carlos taime! « Skelliot’s Weblog | October 12, 2008 | Reply

  16. A local Chiropractor has put together this service.

    It allows you to find a chiropractor at a reduced rate.

    Check it out and let me know what you think please.

    Comment by Dr Steve | October 16, 2008 | Reply

  17. The new Silver Sol is exciting many people around world.  This excitment is quickly spreading from person to person through personal stories and emerging laboratory results.

    Comment by silversol | August 11, 2009 | Reply


Leave a comment